10+ Best Ninja Creami Gelato Recipes

If you’re looking for some delicious gelato recipes to make in the Ninja Creami, we’ve got you covered with several different varieties.

These Ninja Creami gelato recipes are rich, creamy, and indulgent–better than your favorite gelato shoppe!

collage image featuring various Ninja Creami gelato recipes.

Note: This post may contain affiliate links for your convenience. You can read our full disclosure policy here.

It’s no secret that the Ninja Creami has made it easier than ever to make delicious ice creams and sorbets at home.

One of my personal favorite aspects of the machine is that you can make a frozen treat out of almost anything!

You can make ice cream from pudding mix, Ninja Creami sorbet recipes from canned pie filling or canned fruit or even Jello.

You can make dairy free Ninja Creami treats or thick and creamy milkshakes–all with just a few basic ingredients!

Not only that, but you can make high-protein recipes to help you meet your goals.

This makes it easy to customize flavors and cater to dietary needs, without sacrificing flavor.

But until recently, one of the functions I rarely used on my Ninja Creami was the Gelato button.

So I’ve begun experimenting with different flavors and techniques, and I have to say, I’m sold!

These Ninja Creami gelato recipes create super creamy treats your whole family will enjoy.

The Best Gelato Recipes for the Ninja Creami

Not everyone agrees on what makes a gelato different from an ice cream.

Some claim it has to do with egg yolks, others claim it has to do with the ratio of milk to cream.

In my opinion, what matters most is how the final product tastes!

So you’ll see some recipes in this list that use egg yolks, and some that don’t. But all are delicious!

Here are some fantastic gelato recipes to get you started with your Ninja Creami.

1. Ninja Creami Vanilla Gelato

Everybody needs a classic vanilla ice cream recipe, and this Ninja Creami vanilla gelato is one of the best!

It’s silky smooth and has just the right amount of vanilla flavor.

You can enjoy it on its own, or add your favorite mix-in!

2. Ninja Creami Pistachio Gelato

Perhaps one of the most popular flavors at gelato shops is pistachio, and for good reason!

But now you can make your own at home, thanks to this Ninja Creami pistachio gelato recipe.

It’s one of the creamiest treats I’ve ever made. Next time I might add some chopped pistachios as a mix-in!

3. Ninja Creami Coffee Gelato

Coffee lovers, rejoice! This Ninja Creami coffee gelato is a cinch to make, with plenty of coffee flavor.

It’s like enjoying a latte or affogato in dessert form! You can add in some chocolate-covered espresso beans as a mix-in, if you’d like.

4. Ninja Creami Lemon Gelato

This Ninja Creami lemon gelato is an eggless recipe that uses lemon curd to create plenty of cheery flavor!

It’s easy to make and has a nice, creamy texture you’ll love, thanks to milk and cream.

5. Ninja Creami Cake Batter Gelato

Who doesn’t remember licking the spoon full of cake batter?

This Ninja Creami cake batter gelato uses cake mix to give it the classic flavor we know and love.

Don’t want to use cake mix? Try this Ninja Creami cake batter ice cream instead.

6. Ninja Creami Butter Pecan Gelato

This Ninja Creami butter pecan gelato recipe combines egg yolks and corn syrup to create a rich, smooth texture.

Butter extract helps provide the signature flavor, and pecans are mixed in afterward!

7. Ninja Creami Darkest Chocolate Gelato

This one is for the chocolate lovers!

This Ninja Creami dark chocolate gelato incorporates both cocoa powder and dark chocolate chunks for an ultra-rich treat.

8. Ninja Creami Key Lime Pie Gelato

This Ninja Creami key lime pie gelato is like enjoying a slice of the iconic dessert, but in ice cream form!

It’s made tangy with lime curd and lime juice, then graham crackers are mixed in at the end.

This is another egg-free recipe for simpler preparation.

9. Ninja Creami Brownie Batter Gelato

This Ninja Creami brownie batter gelato is made with brownie mix, so you’re sure to notice the classic flavor.

Egg yolks keep the final product rich and smooth–a great way to satisfy your sweet tooth!

10. Ninja Creami Cherry Gelato

This Ninja Creami cherry gelato uses almond extract in the ice cream base, then folds in sweet dark cherries at the end.

The cherries pair perfectly with the almond extract. You could even mix in some chocolate chunks if you want!

11. Ninja Creami Pumpkin Pie Gelato

For a perfect fall treat, try this Ninja Creami pumpkin pie gelato.

Pumpkin puree and pumpkin pie spice combine with egg yolks to create a rich, creamy treat.

More Delicious Ninja Creami Treats

As you can see, there are several flavors of gelato that can be made in the Ninja Creami.

But that’s not all!

If you’re newer to the Ninja Creami, you might find the following resources helpful:

Then, when you’re ready for more delicious recipes, here are some great options to try!

Be sure to save this list to your Ninja Creami board on Pinterest!