Skip to Content

15 Delicious Sugar Free Ninja Creami Recipes

Sharing is caring!

These are some of our favorite Ninja Creami recipes with no added sugar, making them a fantastic way to satisfy your sweet tooth without the guilt.

It’s easy to enjoy sugar free Ninja Creami recipes that taste great! We’re sharing our favorites.

collage image featuring four photos of sugar free Ninja Creami recipes.

Note: This post may contain affiliate links for your convenience. You can read our full disclosure policy here.

When you’re watching your sugar intake, we all know how hard it is to find delicious desserts that don’t have a ton of added sugar.

And let’s be honest, some low carb treats can be plain ol’ disappointing.

But with the Ninja Creami, it’s surprisingly easy to create decadent, guilt-free treats with simple ingredients.

This means you can customize your ingredients based on your dietary needs, which makes it super appealing for a lot of folks.

Whether you need dairy-free Ninja Creami recipes, Weight-Watchers friendly recipes, or sugar-free Ninja Creami recipes, you’re in luck!

We’re sharing some delicious Ninja Creami recipes with no added sugar, so you can enjoy a tasty frozen dessert without a lot of effort.

Ninja Creami Sugar Free vs. No Added Sugar

It’s important to note that there’s a difference between “sugar free” and “no added sugar.”

There are many Ninja Creami recipes that use fruit or dairy products, which contain natural sugars.

Then there are other products that include added sugars, beyond what’s naturally occurring in the ingredients.

I’ll do my best to make note of those in this list, because different people have different thresholds for what they can tolerate.

If you need sugar-free desserts, you’ll want to avoid dairy and fruits.

1. Ninja Creami Sugar Free Chocolate Ice Cream

Everybody needs a good Ninja Creami sugar-free chocolate ice cream recipe, and this is it!

It’s rich and creamy, and it feels decadent and indulgent.

You can opt for nondairy milk and cream if you need to avoid the natural sugars.

2. Ninja Creaim Sugar Free Pistachio Ice Cream

This sugar free pistachio ice cream is one of my personal favorites.

It tastes just like your favorite gelato shop, but without any added sugar!

As with other recipes, you can skip the dairy if needed.

3. Ninja Creami Sugar Free Vanilla Ice Cream

I love the versatility of this sugar free vanilla ice cream.

Not only can you eat it as-is, but it’s also a great base for your favorite mix-ins.

Add sugar-free cookies, candy, or nuts to change it up!

Opting for dairy-free ingredients will decrease the naturally-occurring sugars, too.

4. Ninja Creami No Added Sugar Strawberry Frozen Yogurt

This strawberry frozen yogurt includes natural sugars from strawberries and yogurt, but there’s no added sugar.

Instead, monkfruit sweetener is used to help macerate the berries, bringing out their flavorful juices.

It’s an indulgent treat my kids repeatedly ask me to make!

5. Ninja Creami Sugar Free Salted Caramel Ice Cream

This recipe uses a low-carb caramel sauce to create that rich, buttery flavor we’ve come to expect.

It’s a simple recipe that uses unsweetened almond milk to cut down on the natural sugar.

6. Ninja Creami Sugar Free Mint Chocolate Chip Ice Cream

This easy mint chocolate chip recipe uses sugar-free pudding mix and sugar-free chocolate chips to create a tasty treat.

It also includes some protein powder to increase the protein content!

7. Ninja Creami Sugar Free Orange Creamsicle Ice Cream

Sugar-free orange Jell-O mix is the secret ingredient in this sugar-free creamsicle ice cream.

Plus, it packs a protein punch, so it’s an easy treat you can feel good about.

8. Ninja Creami No Added Sugar Blueberry Cheesecake Ice Cream

This blueberry cheesecake ice cream uses fresh blueberries, so it contains natural sugars from those.

Some stevia gives it added sweetness, and it does include some dairy as well.

So it has no added sugars, but still some natural sugars. It’s also high-protein!

9. Ninja Creami Sugar Free Coffee Ice Cream

This sugar-free coffee ice cream uses monk fruit sweetener and espresso powder to create a sweet coffee ice cream.

It’s easy to make, because you just blend everything together and freeze.

10. Ninja Creami Sugar Free Butter Pecan Ice Cream

Sugar free instant pudding mix and almond milk serve as the base for this ice cream.

Add in some butter and roasted pecans, and you’re in business!

11. Ninja Creami Sugar Free Banana Ice Cream

Most Ninja Creami banana recipes use actual bananas for sweetness, but that adds natural sugars.

This recipe uses sugar-free banana pudding mix and banana extract, so it has plenty of flavor but no sugar!

It does use a little bit of dairy, which you can swap out for nondairy alternatives if needed.

12. Ninja Creami Sugar Free Peach Ice Cream

This sugar-free peach ice cream uses peach extract instead of actual peaches, so there’s no fruit sugars to contend with.

It’s a perfect treat for summer!

13. Ninja Creami No Added Sugar Chocolate Cheesecake Ice Cream

This chocolate cheesecake recipe uses liquid saccharine instead of sugar!

It does include some fat-free cheese squares (such as Laughing Cow cheese), which would have a little bit of natural sugars.

14. Ninja Creami Sugar Free Cotton Candy Ice Cream

This recipe uses liquid stevia for sweetness, and cotton candy extract for flavor!

It’s a fun, colorful treat that makes a great, healthier alternative to the carnival classic.

15. Ninja Creami Sugar Free Carrot Cake Ice Cream

If you love carrot cake, you have to try this carrot cake ice cream!

It uses the warm spices we expect in a slice of carrot cake, plus some shredded carrots and nuts.

But it’s sweetened with zero-calorie brown sweetener, making it a sugar-free treat you can feel good about.

Converting Ninja Creami Recipes to Be Sugar Free

If you come across a Ninja Creami recipe that you like, but it isn’t sugar-free, there are some simple tweaks you can make.

Here some some adaptations that can help decrease the sugar content.

Choose an Alternative Sweetener

This tip may seem obvious, but sometimes it’s hard to know how to make adjustments.

If a recipe calls for regular granulated sugar, I like to substitute monk fruit sweetener (such as Lakanto).

Not only does it taste great, but it’s a cup-for-cup alternative. So whatever amount of sugar the recipe calls for, you’ll use the same amount of monkfruit sweetener.

If you have other sweeteners that you like, feel free to use those and adjust the amount to taste.

Keep in mind that the mixture will taste slightly less sweet once it’s been frozen.

Use Sugar-Free Pudding

Instant sugar-free pudding is a great option for providing sweetness and flavor to your creations, but without the added sugar!

Plus, it’s available in a wide array of flavors, so there are so many possibilities.

Skip the Dairy

Because dairy contains some natural sugars, you can always opt for nondairy alternatives.

Almond milk is a popular choice instead of dairy milk.

I don’t recommend completely eliminating all fat if you’re wanting a creamy result, but canned coconut cream is a great alternative to heavy cream.

Enjoying Lower Sugar Ninja Creami Desserts

Hopefully these recipes and tips help you see that your low-sugar desserts don’t have to taste like cardboard!

There are so many delicious options to choose from, while still cutting back on sugar intake.

Whether you’re wanting an indulgent chocolate ice cream or a refreshing strawberry frozen yogurt, you can enjoy a tasty treat that meets your dietary needs.

More Ninja Creami Recipes to Try:

Be sure to save this list of sugar-free recipes to your Ninja Creami board on Pinterest!

collage image featuring Ninja Creami recipes made with no added sugar.